Donald J. Trump was inaugurated as the 47th President of the U.S.A on January 20th 2025. Alongside a commitment to reinstate TikTok he has also suggested / threatened that Canada might become America’s 51st state. Regular Radioinfo contributor Dave Charles, a former Australian radio media consultant, six decade veteran of the industry and inducted last year into the Canada Radio Hall of Fame, provided these thoughts on the pros and cons of such a decision, for radio, and beyond.
Exclusive to Radioinfo by Dave Charles, CEO of Media RESULTS Inc.
On every radio station, TV channel, in every bar, coffee shop and meeting place, Canadians are wondering what our future will be like if we became part of the U.S.
I can tell now with a great deal of certainty that most Canadians I speak with are against such a move. Let me explain why.
The idea of Canada joining the United States as a 51st state is a provocative concept that brings with it a mix of potential benefits and significant challenges. From an economic standpoint, integration could offer considerable advantages. Canada, with its abundant natural resources and highly skilled workforce, could benefit from the larger U.S. economy and market access. A unified economy could lead to reduced trade barriers, streamlined regulations, and enhanced business opportunities, bolstering industries like energy, technology, and manufacturing across the continent.
Politically, joining the U.S. could provide Canada with increased geopolitical influence. As part of the United States, Canada would gain a voice in one of the world’s most powerful political entities, potentially amplifying its impact on global issues such as climate change, international security, and trade policy. Canada could also benefit from the robust military infrastructure of the United States, enhancing its national security and reducing defense expenditures.
Culturally, integration might foster greater collaboration and exchange between the two nations, enriching both societies. Shared language, similar values, and existing cultural ties could ease the transition, while increased mobility for citizens between the two countries could boost educational opportunities, tourism, and innovation. Canadians could also benefit from access to the U.S. health system’s specialised services and cutting-edge medical research, albeit with differences in approach to healthcare funding and delivery.
It is essential to consider the complexities and trade-offs. Canada would face the challenge of preserving its distinct identity, policies, and institutions within a much larger political entity. Issues such as differences in healthcare systems, social policies, and governance structures would require significant negotiation and compromise. While the potential benefits are seem worthy, the decision to join the U.S. would involve balancing national sovereignty with the opportunities afforded by integration into a global superpower.
Radio wise, the CRTC (Canadian Radio, Telecommunications Commission) would cease to exist. No more regulations regarding Canadian content music, spoken word basically freeing the Radio industry for private and CBC to do whatever it wants to be viable and profitable. At the moment Canadian radio must play 35% Cancon.
For me personally; The U.S. second amendment with ‘the right to carry arms’ is a deal breaker. The last thing you want is to give more access to guns of all makes and sizes.
Canadians pay too much in taxes at the provincial and national level. Joining the U.S. would give us tax weary Canadians more money in our pockets. That’s a good thing.
Canadians overall are suspicious of Trump in many ways. He doesn’t like to fact-check and he tells too many porky pies. It remains to be seen whether Trump has learned anything from his first term as President.
About the Author
Dave Charles, CEO Media RESULTS Inc.
Mobile: +1 289 242 8313.
Email: [email protected]
Mr Trump was officially inaugurated today our time 21-01-2025 0400.
I believe his modus operandi is to provoke affected parties into deal.
Canada is not the only country he wants to make a deal. The proposed takeover would require a referendum of the Canadian people to approve the integration into the US.
The article talked about the laws such as broadcasting laws applicable to Canada.
How such laws could be harmonised with the US's FCC as well as Canada's CBC being harmonised with NPR especially the funding of the CBC.
Similarly there are issues with regards to taxation and health.
A leader from one nation cannot assume sovereignty of another territory is a fait accomplis.
Canada and the takeover of Greenland are not mere words of fiat and it will be done.
Nations belonging to the BRICS union may face 100% from the new administration.
In the end actions speak louder than words. It appears the current president is using provocative words to encourage negotiations. The president is the author of "The Art Of The Deal".
Dealing is how things will happen.
Thanks
Anthony, Canada is not the only story in the negotiation game, Strathfield South, in the land of the Wangal and Darug People's of the Eora Nation.